Report ng IIRC sa Rizal Park Hostage Taking

 Dear insansapinas,

Sinumite na ang report ng IIRC at ano fa eh di ganoon na nga ang mga obserbasyon at mga taong kakasuhan daw. Una ay ayaw nilang i-publish. Kaya lang binira sila ng mga congressmen.  
Ikalawa ay dadalhin daw ang report sa China ni VP Binay at DFA Secretary Romulo. Ngayon isinumite na lang sa Chinese Ambassador sa Maynila. 

President Benigno Aquino on Monday said the IIRC recommended the filing of criminal or administrative complaints against 12 individuals and 3 media companies for the hostage crisis.
Among those facing possible administrative or criminal charges are national police chief Jesus Verzosa; then Manila Police District chief Rodolfo Magtibay, National Capital Region Police Office chief Leocadio Santiago, chief hostage negotiator Manila Superintendent Orlando Yebra, Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) Undersecretary Rico Puno, Chief Inspector Santiago Pascual, head of the Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) team, Ombudsman Merceditas Gutierrez, Deputy Ombudsman Emilio Gonzalez III,  TV5's Erwin Tulfo, Radio Mo Nationwide's (RMN) Michael Rogas, Manila Mayor Alfredo Lim, Manila Vice-Mayor Isko Moreno, and broadcast networks GMA-7, ABS-CBN, and TV5.

Meron nga kayang ulong gugulong?

Galing kay Ellen Tordesillas, ito ang ilan sa mga kasalanan ng grupo.

3. The presentation to Mendoza of the letter from the Ombudsman and the resulting breakdown of negotiations. At this point the expectations of Mendoza that his demand for and Order for reinstatement was high because this was reinforced by the assurances from the Ombudsman and the Vice Mayor.
4.The acts, omissions and reaction, of the authorities concerned with resolving the crisis situation, to the initial breakdown (the third Critical Incident).
Immediately upon return of the Negotiating Team, with Gregorio (brother of hostage-taker Senior Inspector Rolando mendoza, to the Advance Command Post, Col. Yebra accused Gregorio of being a conspirator and an accessory. Whether he was shouting or not is not really material. The fact is Col. Yebra displayed his loss of focus on the task at hand. He was distracted by a peripheral matter.
More important to addressing the actuations of Gregorio was re-building the confidence of Mendoza, re-establishing contact with him, and salvaging the negotiations that clearly broke down, by working on the offered alternative solution. Instead, Col. Yebra, Mayor Lim, Gen. Magtibay, and other police officers present focused on handling the peripheral matter involving Gregorio resulting to Mayor Lim’s order for Gregorio’s arrest, looking for handcuffs, and conferring on how to handle Gregorio. By attending to the peripheral matter, precious time to salvage the negotiations, already critical at this late hour of the crisis situation, was lost. The windows of opportunity were closing.
5.The arrest of Gregorio Mendoza upon orders of Mayor Lim.
Viewed in perspective, this was the proximate cause of the chain of events that led to Mendoza’s shooting at the Hostages. The potential adverse reaction of Mendoza to an arrest of Gregorio was not lost to Mayor Lim. This is borne by his instruction to the escorting officers to use the back door of the Advance Command Post to avoid media. That Mendoza was viewing television at this time was already known at this point. The instruction to avoid media should be taken in this context.
6. The departure of Mayor Lim and General Magtibay from the Advance Command Post at a crucial time .
Immediately preceding events aggravated by lack of evaluation of their implications, compounded by error in judgment, resulted in the Sixth Critical Event. The absence of Mayor Lim and General Magtibay in the Advance Command Post created a vacuum in command or decision makers. This resulted in the inability of those present to handle crisis events as they unfolded. Everything that Mayor Lim and General Magtibay hoped to accomplish at Emerald Restaurant, including taking a meal, could have been accomplished at the Advance Command Post and even better because they would have been in a position to react to events promptly.
The most significant of events that transpired after Mayor Lim and General Magtibay left the Advance Command Post were the coverage of Gregorio being arrested, the deadlines being given by Mendoza before he starts shooting the hostages and the actual shooting of hostages.
7. The inefficient, disorganized and stalled assault brought about the Seventh Critical Incident. The manner by which the assault on the bus, to rescue the hostages and take down Mendoza, was carried out was the convergence of efficiencies omitted, and inefficiencies committed, through-out the day.
There was an absence of relevant intelligence information that could have aided the formulation and execution of a proper assault plan, including the choice of equipment needed to efficiently carry out the same. The information about the emergency exit door, the emergency button to open the main door and the strength of material of the window panels were vital information. Unfortunately, from the very start, there was no intelligence gathering sub-group activated.
8. The absence of an organized Post Assault Plan.
What transpired immediately after the neutralization of Mendoza clearly demonstrated the absence of a Post Assault Plan or the inefficient manner such a plan was carried out, if indeed there was a plan. There was no crowd control that resulted in by standers rushing to the immediate vicinity of the bus thereby hampering evacuation of hostages. Media reporters were even allowed to board ambulances. There was also no clear coordination with medical facilities as shown by the testimony that victims were rejected by one hospital because they could no longer be accommodated. Time was lost in traveling to the next nearest hospital.

Nang unang mga arangkada ng balitang hostage taking, nagcomment na ako tungkol sa mga maling ginawa ng mga taong responsibilidad sa pagsolve ng problema ng hostage taking sa Rizal Park. Sa dami ba naman ng nasusubaybayan kong hostage taking dito sa US, sa mga pelikulang napapanood ko, sa mga series na tungkol sa hostage taking at sa mga nobelang kung saan may mga hostage taker, malalaman muna na talagang may mali. Kaya lang may isang bulag(panatiko), bingi (ang kaniyang sinusulat lang raw ang ginagaya ng mga tao at makitid ang utak na baka raw ako ang maging hostage taker dahil ako'y expert. Mantakin mo yon. bwahahaha. Ang mga pikon talaga, pag hindi ka masagot, bibirahin ka ng personal. Pag babae ka babastusin ka.



Pinaysaamerika